Skip to content

CheckedTwice vs. WishApp (2026 Comparison)

CheckedTwice compared with WishApp, two gift registry apps side by side

CheckedTwice has run a closed family gift registry since 2009. This comparison looks at how its invite-only setup holds up against WishApp on apps, sharing and the gifting features that decide which one your family keeps using.

Last updated: October 2026

CheckedTwice is a free, invite-only family registry with a clever closed-group view. But its phone apps haven't been updated since 2014, and everyone has to create an account before they can see a list. WishApp is free too, runs on current phones and desktops, and lets friends reserve gifts from a single link. It's the CheckedTwice alternative we'd pick.

Feature comparison

CheckedTwice's closed family group wins a few rows: one shared dashboard, surprise gifts added by relatives, and accounts for kids.

FeatureCheckedTwiceWishApp
Pricing & value
Free forever, no subscriptionAlways freeAlways free
Unlimited lists and itemsUnlimitedUnlimited
No adsNo adsNo ads
Platforms & devices
Current iPhone and Android appsLast updated 2014iOS + Android
macOS desktop appNoneYes
Browser extensionBookmarklet onlySix browsers
Raycast quick-addNoYes
Sharing & privacy
Friends view without an accountAccount requiredOpen link
Closed family group dashboardYesFollow each list
QR code for any listNoYes
Multiple currenciesNot documentedAny currency
Gifting features
Hidden reservations (owner cannot see)YesYes
Surprise gifts added by othersYesCollaborators only
Dependent accounts for kidsYesNo
Self-service Secret SantaEmail supportBuilt in
Reserved and received trackingNoYes
Ease of use
Add from any store by pasting a linkUnreliable scraperAuto-fills
Save a product in one click while browsing2013 bookmarkletYes
Modern, actively maintained interface2013-era designYes

A closer look

Pricing and value

Both apps are free, with no premium tier, no paywall and no ads. CheckedTwice has called itself 'Always free' since 2009 and stuck to it. WishApp is free too, with unlimited lists and items, and it earns from affiliate links rather than from you. So price won't decide this one. What you get for free will.

Platforms and devices

Apps are where the gap is widest. CheckedTwice is a website plus iPhone and Android apps stuck at version 1.0.8 since August 2014, and the iPhone app averages about one star. On a current phone they barely work. WishApp has current apps for iPhone, iPad, Android phones and tablets and macOS, plus extensions for Chrome, Edge, Firefox, Opera, Safari and Brave and a Raycast add-on. Your list is the same on every device, and all of it is still maintained.

Sharing, privacy and reservations

The two apps take opposite approaches here. CheckedTwice is closed. Every family member has to create an account and accept an email invite before they can see a single list. In return it has one real strength: a shared dashboard with everyone's lists under one login. WishApp works the other way. You share one link, anyone can open it without signing up, and gifts can be reserved in secret. Both hide reservations from the list's owner, so the surprise survives either way.

Gifting and group features

CheckedTwice has some clever family features that WishApp doesn't have. Any member can put a 'surprise gift' on someone else's list, hidden from that person, and a parent can run dependent sub-accounts for kids or grandparents. For a close family where everyone already has an account, those are real wins. WishApp has collaborative lists, a reserved-and-received archive that remembers who gave what, and Secret Santa built in. CheckedTwice has Secret Santa too, but you have to email support to switch it on.

Ease of use and adding items

CheckedTwice's main way to add items is an Amazon keyword search. Links from other stores go through a scraper that couldn't pull Etsy photos even back in 2013. Its one-click tool is a 2013 bookmarklet, not a real extension, and the whole site looks its age. WishApp takes any product link and fills in the title, image and price, or saves it in one click from the browser extension. Its interface is current and still being updated.

Which one is right for you?

Choose CheckedTwice if…

  • Your whole family already has CheckedTwice accounts and you want every list in one shared dashboard under a single login.
  • You like that any relative can quietly add a surprise gift to someone else's list without the recipient seeing it.
  • You need dependent accounts so a parent can manage lists for young kids or non-tech grandparents.
  • You only use a desktop browser and don't mind a 2013-era interface or asking everyone to sign up first.

Choose WishApp if…

  • You want friends and family to open a list and reserve a gift from one link, with no app to install.
  • You want current apps on iPhone, iPad, Android and macOS, not phone apps last updated in 2014.
  • You add gifts from any store and want a one-click browser extension that actually fills in the details.
  • You want to run Secret Santa without emailing support, or keep a reserved-and-received history of who gave what.

CheckedTwice FAQ

Yes. CheckedTwice has had no premium tier, ads or in-app purchases since it launched in 2009. Every feature is free, including unlimited lists, family invites and claiming gifts. WishApp is free the same way and has no paid plan at all.

On paper, yes. In practice, not really. CheckedTwice's iPhone and Android apps are stuck at version 1.0.8 from August 2014, and the iPhone app averages about one star, so on a current phone they barely work. Most people just use the website. WishApp has current, maintained apps for iPhone, iPad, Android and macOS.

WishApp, if you want phone apps that still get updates. It's free, runs on current phones, desktops and six browsers, and lets people reserve gifts straight from a shared link. CheckedTwice's strengths are its closed family dashboard and dependent accounts, so if one shared family view is what you want most, look at CheckedTwice first.

No. CheckedTwice has no public share link. Anyone who wants to see a list has to create an account and accept an email invite to your family group first. WishApp works the other way. Anyone with the link can open your list without an account and reserve a gift in seconds.

Not a real one. CheckedTwice has a 'Want It!' bookmarklet from 2013 that you drag to your bookmarks bar, but nothing in the Chrome, Firefox, Edge or Safari extension stores. WishApp publishes maintained extensions for six browsers that save any product in one click.

Yes, but you have to ask for it. CheckedTwice's Secret Santa mode isn't in the interface, so you email support to have it switched on for your family group. Once it's on, claimed items show 'Claimed by someone' instead of a name. WishApp has Secret Santa built in, with no support email needed.

CheckedTwice doesn't offer an export, so moving means adding your items again rather than importing them in bulk. It doesn't take long in WishApp. Links from any store come in with their title, image and price filled in, and the browser extension saves items in one click.

Compare other wishlist apps

Choosing between more than two apps? Our ranking of the best wishlist apps compares them side by side.

Getting ready for the holidays? Draw names for Secret Santa with a wishlist for everyone in the group, or use our Christmas list maker to share one list with the whole family.

Send one link, get the gifts you want

Save gifts from any store in one free wishlist. Friends reserve in secret, so nobody doubles up.

Make my wishlist

4.9(1,000+ reviews worldwide)