Skip to content

Wishlists vs. WishApp (2026 Comparison)

Wishlists compared with WishApp, two wishlist apps side by side

Wishlists is a polished app from a German developer, and plenty of people swear by it for Secret Santa. The differences from WishApp come down to price, which devices you can use, and what your friends have to do before they can reserve a gift.

Last updated: October 2026

Wishlists is a lovely phone app, and its Secret Santa draw is one of the best around. But it has no web app or browser extension, and gift-givers have to install it before they can reserve anything. WishApp is free forever, works in any browser and on desktop, and friends reserve straight from the link without installing anything. Of the Wishlists alternatives, WishApp is the one we'd pick.

Feature comparison

Wishlists wins on its in-store barcode scanner and an app in 29 languages.

FeatureWishlistsWishApp
Pricing & value
Free forever, no subscriptionFreemiumEverything free
Unlimited lists and itemsUnlimitedUnlimited
No adsNever any adsNo ads
All features included, no paywallSome paidYes
Platforms & devices
iPhone, iPad and Android appsiOS + AndroidiOS + Android
Full web app to create and manageMobile onlyYes
Browser extensionsNoneFive browsers
Raycast quick-addNoYes
Sharing & reservations
Friends view a shared list without an accountYesYes
Reserve a gift without installing the appApp requiredNo account needed
Hidden reservations (owner cannot see)YesYes
Collaborative listsNoYes
Gifting features
Secret Santa / gift exchangeExcellentYes
Reserved and received trackingReserved onlyBoth
Group gifting / chip-inNoYes
Barcode scanner for in-store itemsYesNot offered
Ease of use
Add from any store by pasting a linkAuto-importAuto-fills
Save a product in one click while browsingNo extensionYes
In-app language support29 languagesEnglish + Danish

A closer look

Pricing and value

Both apps are free to start, and neither shows ads. In WishApp every feature is free forever, and there's no premium tier. Wishlists is freemium: the core is free, but extras like priority flags and custom list images need a subscription, which runs from $1.99 a month to a $29.99 lifetime unlock. The awkward part is that Wishlists doesn't say which features are paid, so you find the paywall partway through using it.

Platforms and devices

Devices are the biggest gap. Wishlists has no web app and no browser extension, so if you shop on a laptop you have to pick up your phone to add anything. Its Mac version is an iOS Catalyst build and needs an Apple Silicon Mac. WishApp runs on iPhone, iPad, Android, macOS and the web, with extensions for Chrome, Edge, Firefox, Opera and Safari and a Raycast add-on. Your list is the same on all of them.

Sharing and reservations

Sharing is where most people decide. In both apps, friends can open a shared link and see the list without an account. To reserve a gift on Wishlists, though, they have to download the app and sign up. Reviewers complain about this more than anything else, and it's how people end up buying the same gift twice. WishApp lets anyone reserve straight from the link, no app needed. Both apps hide reservations from the list owner.

Gifting and group features

Wishlists' Secret Santa is the feature people praise most, and it deserves the credit. It has a spinning draw wheel, budgets and invitations, and one reviewer ran it for a group of more than 20. It's arguably more polished than WishApp's. WishApp covers more ground: it runs Secret Santa too, and adds collaborative lists, group gifting and a reserved-and-received view that remembers who each gift came from. Wishlists has no group chip-in and no shared editing. It does have one thing WishApp doesn't: a barcode scanner for adding products while you're in a shop.

Ease of use and adding items

Both apps are easy to use day to day, and Wishlists looks great. Reviewers call it 'stunning' and 'minimalist', and saving from your phone's share sheet is quick. Reliability and reach let it down. Some users get 'page could not be opened' errors when importing from certain shops, and you can't add anything from a desktop. WishApp fills in the title, image and price from any link, and its extension saves a product in one click while you browse. Wishlists' app comes in 29 languages, while WishApp's mobile app is English and Danish only.

Which one should you use?

Choose Wishlists if…

  • You run a Secret Santa every year and want a draw wheel with budgets and invitations that works for big groups.
  • You do your shopping on your phone and rarely use a laptop, so a phone-only app won't hold you back.
  • You shop in physical stores and want to scan a product's barcode to add it on the spot.
  • Design matters a lot to you, and you don't mind paying a few dollars for the extras.

Choose WishApp if…

  • You want friends to reserve gifts straight from a link, with no app to install.
  • You add gifts from a laptop and want a one-click extension for Chrome, Edge, Firefox, Opera or Safari.
  • You want every feature free forever, with nothing behind a paywall.
  • You want a full web app and a product with a team behind it, not a phone app run by one developer.

Wishlists FAQ

The basics are free: making lists, adding items, sharing, reservations and Secret Santa. Some extras, like priority flags and custom list images, need a subscription, from $1.99 a month up to a $29.99 lifetime unlock, and the app doesn't list exactly which features are paid. WishApp has no paid tier, so every feature is free.

No. Wishlists has apps for iPhone, iPad and Android, but no web app for creating or managing lists and no extension for any browser. Friends can view a shared list in a browser, but you can't add items from a desktop. WishApp has a full web app plus extensions for Chrome, Edge, Firefox, Opera and Safari.

If your friends won't install an app, WishApp. It's free forever, works on phones, desktops and in five browsers, and friends can reserve gifts without installing anything. Wishlists is stronger on Secret Santa and has a barcode scanner. If those two matter most to you, try Wishlists first.

Yes, and it's the complaint that comes up most in its reviews. Friends can open your shared list in a browser without an account, but to mark an item as reserved they have to download the Wishlists app and sign up. Anyone who skips that step can't reserve, which is how duplicate gifts happen. WishApp lets anyone reserve straight from the link, no app needed.

Yes, it's one of the app's strongest features. Wishlists has a dedicated gift-exchange tool with a spinning draw wheel, a budget per event and invitations for participants, and one reviewer used it with a group of more than 20. WishApp has Secret Santa built in too, alongside collaborative lists and group gifting, so either app will do the job.

Yes. In a shop, you can scan a product's barcode to add it to a list, which is handy if you shop in person and unusual for a wishlist app. WishApp has no barcode scanner. Instead, you add items from their product link or with one click in the browser extension.

Yes. Paste the link to your Wishlists list into WishApp's import and the items come over in one go. After that, WishApp only needs a product link to fetch the title, image and price, and the browser extension saves items in one click while you shop.

Wishlists is built and run by one developer, Christian Konnerth, in Nürnberg, Germany. It launched in 2020, has strong app store ratings, and says it ranks #1 for 'Wunschliste' (wishlist) in the German App Store. The flip side is that it all rests on one person. WishApp has a team behind it, which makes it easier to keep going over the long term.

Compare other wishlist apps

Choosing between more than two apps? Our ranking of the best wishlist apps compares them side by side.

Getting ready for the holidays? Draw names for Secret Santa with a wishlist for everyone in the group, or use our Christmas list maker to share one list with the whole family.

Send one link, get the gifts you want

Save gifts from any store in one free wishlist. Friends reserve in secret, so nobody doubles up.

Make my wishlist

4.9(1,000+ reviews worldwide)