Pricing and value
Both apps are genuinely free, with no premium tier and nothing to unlock. GoWish makes its money from affiliate links and 700+ brand partners, which is fine. The catch is what that buys for the user. GoWish's inspiration feed is full of sponsored, promoted products, and reviewers say the trending page reads like an ad engine. WishApp earns from affiliate commissions too, but shows no ads, no sponsored feed, and runs no behavioral tracking.
Platforms and devices
GoWish is mobile-first, and its iPhone and Android apps are strong. Beyond that it thins out fast. The Mac version is just the iPhone app running on Apple Silicon, flagged 'not verified for macOS'. The Chrome extension is stuck at version 0.0.2 from February 2023 with around 1,000 users. No Firefox, Edge, Safari, or Raycast. WishApp ships native apps on iPhone, iPad, Android and macOS, plus maintained extensions for five browsers and a Raycast add-on.
Sharing and the account wall
This is the big one. With GoWish, anyone you share a list with has to create a GoWish account before they can even view it, let alone reserve a gift. For a grandparent or a casual friend, that is often a dead end. WishApp shares with one link that opens for anyone, no sign-up, and they can secretly reserve a gift right there. Both hide reservations from the list owner, so the surprise survives either way.
Privacy and the feed
GoWish leans social. It has an inspiration feed, a creator universe, and brand follows, which some people love. But that layer runs on data: the app collects your date of birth and gender at sign-up and, per its App Store disclosure, tracks usage across apps and websites. WishApp has no social feed and no creator program, and it doesn't ask for your birthday or track you. Quieter, and private by design.
Gifting and group features
For sharing a single list, both apps cover the basics: add items, share, reserve in secret. GoWish adds collaborative and proxy lists, so a couple can build a wedding list together. WishApp matches the collaboration and goes further with Secret Santa for organising a gift exchange, plus a 'received' archive where you can note who a gift came from. GoWish has no Secret Santa and no received tracking.
Ease of use and adding items
GoWish's core flow is quick and clean when it works: paste a link, get a populated item, share. But the auto-fill leans on its affiliate partner network, so smaller and independent stores often come back as blank cards or 'no product found'. Android users also report frequent crashes and a currency bug that forces euros. WishApp runs a dedicated scraper that pulls the title, image and price from any URL, and saves products in one click from the browser extension.