Skip to content

Elfster vs. WishApp (2026 Comparison)

Elfster compared with WishApp, two gifting apps side by side

Elfster has run office Secret Santa draws since 2004. This comparison with WishApp looks at the name draw, the apps and browsers each one supports, and whether either is worth keeping for the other fifty weeks of the year.

Last updated: October 2026

No one runs an automated Secret Santa draw better than Elfster, with exclusions, budgets and groups that come back each year. But it shows ads, works only in English and is built for December. WishApp is free with no ads, works on every platform all year, and fills in items from any store link. Of the Elfster alternatives, it's the one we recommend.

Feature comparison

Both apps run an automated draw with exclusions. Elfster also runs White Elephant and Yankee Swap, which WishApp doesn't.

FeatureElfsterWishApp
Pricing & value
Free to useFreeFree forever
No adsAd-supportedNo ads
Unlimited lists and itemsUnlimitedUnlimited
No data sellingAffiliate + adsNever sold
Platforms & devices
iPhone and Android appsBothBoth
Native iPad and tablet layoutsNot optimizedYes
macOS desktop appNoYes
Browser extensionsChrome only, 2.7★Five browsers
Raycast quick-addNoYes
Sharing & privacy
Share with one linkYesYes
Friends reserve from a shared linkNeeds an accountYes
Hidden reservations on any listExchanges onlyAny list
More than one languageEnglish only26 languages
Gifting & group features
Secret Santa / gift exchangeYesYes
Automated name draw with exclusionsBest in classYes
White Elephant / Yankee Swap formatsYesNo
Reserved and received trackingNoYes
Collaborative listsExchanges onlyYes
Ease of use
Add from any store by pasting a linkUnreliableAuto-fills
Save a product in one click while browsingWeak extensionYes
Works year-round, not just holidaysHoliday-focusedAny occasion

Where each one wins

Pricing and value

Both apps are free, so the real cost is your attention. Elfster earns affiliate commissions, shows ads in the free version and pushes sponsored gift guides throughout. WishApp also earns from affiliate links, but it shows no ads and sells no data. You pay nothing for either one. WishApp just leaves out the promoted clutter.

Platforms and devices

WishApp covers more devices. Elfster has solid iPhone and Android apps, both well rated and actively updated, and that's about where it stops. The iPad version isn't optimized, there's no native Mac app, and its only browser extension, for Chrome, sits at 2.7 stars. There's nothing for Firefox, Safari or Edge. WishApp has native tablet layouts, a Mac app, working extensions for five browsers and a Raycast add-on, so the same list is with you on every device.

Sharing, privacy and reservations

The two split here. Elfster prevents duplicate gifts by letting people mark an item as purchased for others to see, but that only works inside a formal exchange, and a participant needs an account just to mark a gift. WishApp hides reservations on any shared list: the owner never sees who claimed what, and friends reserve straight from the link whenever they like. For an ordinary birthday list shared with friends, that difference matters.

Gifting and group features

Elfster wins the draw, easily. Its name-draw engine handles exclusions for couples, kids and repeat years, runs White Elephant and Yankee Swap, sets budgets and deadlines, and remembers your group from one year to the next. WishApp's Secret Santa handles exclusions too, but it has no White Elephant or Yankee Swap. You can reuse a group with its members and exclusions, but it doesn't automatically avoid last year's pairings. It adds collaborative lists and tracking for what you've reserved and received instead. If an organized office draw is the whole reason you're here, Elfster does it better.

Ease of use and adding items

Setting up an Elfster exchange is quick, and the app guides you through it. Adding the gifts is harder. You either search Elfster's catalog or paste a URL that often comes back without an image, and on mobile the flow is broken enough that reviewers complain about it. WishApp takes any product link and fills in the title, image and price, or saves the product in one click from the browser extension, so there's no catalog to fight with.

Making the call

Choose Elfster if…

  • You run a Secret Santa, White Elephant or Yankee Swap every year and want the best automated name draw, with exclusion rules and budgets.
  • You organize the same family or office group every year and want Elfster to remember who's in it.
  • You want wishlists tied to an exchange, where each person's list is visible only to their assigned giver.
  • You like browsing curated gift guides and trending picks, and ads in the free version don't bother you.

Choose WishApp if…

  • You want a clean, ad-free wishlist to share for birthdays, weddings or any other occasion, at any time of year.
  • You add gifts from any store and want the title, image and price filled in for you, or saved in one click while you browse.
  • You want friends to open your list without an account and reserve gifts from the same link, while you never see what's reserved.
  • You use an iPad, a Mac, Firefox, Safari or Edge, or you need a language other than English.

Elfster FAQ

Yes. Creating exchanges, drawing names, building wishlists and shopping the gift guides are all free. Elfster earns money from affiliate links and shows ads in the free version. A few third-party sites mention a premium tier at about $4.99 a month, but Elfster's own marketing calls it '100% free', so if a paid tier exists, it's barely promoted. WishApp is free with no ads and no premium tier.

Yes. Elfster has well-rated iPhone and Android apps, both actively maintained, and the iOS app averages 4.9 stars across 331,000 ratings. There's no native Mac app, and the iPad version isn't optimized. WishApp has native apps for iPhone, iPad, Android and macOS, plus five browser extensions.

For everyday wishlists, WishApp. It's free with no ads, works on every platform all year, hides reservations on any list and fills in items from any store link. Elfster's one real edge is its automated Secret Santa draw, so if an organized office or family exchange is all you need, Elfster still does that better.

Sort of. Elfster's 'Wish It!' extension exists for Chrome, but it has 2.7 stars, around 40,000 installs and a reputation for being unreliable, and there's no Firefox, Safari or Edge version. WishApp keeps its extensions for Chrome, Edge, Firefox, Opera and Safari up to date, and each one saves a product in one click.

Too many emails is the complaint people raise most about Elfster. People who only accepted an invitation, or signed up just to mark a gift as purchased, describe a stream of promotional emails that are hard to unsubscribe from. WishApp complies with GDPR, doesn't send spam, and lets you delete your account and all your data.

You can, but the product is built around the holiday draw, and its traffic drops about 88% from December to January. Standalone wishlists work, but importing items from other stores is clunky, and reservations stay hidden only inside a formal exchange. WishApp is built for any occasion at any time of year, with hidden reservations on every list.

Yes. Paste your Elfster wishlist's share link into WishApp's import and your items come over in one go. Adding new ones is quick too: paste a product link and the title, image and price fill in, with no catalog to search and nothing to type by hand.

Yes, WishApp has Secret Santa, so a basic gift exchange is covered. Its draw handles exclusions, so couples don't draw each other, and you can reuse a group the next year with its members and exclusions. What it doesn't have is the rest of Elfster's engine: White Elephant and Yankee Swap formats, and a draw that automatically avoids last year's pairings. WishApp handles a simple exchange fine. For a complicated annual office draw, Elfster goes further.

Compare other wishlist apps

Choosing between more than two apps? Our ranking of the best wishlist apps compares them side by side.

Getting ready for the holidays? Draw names for Secret Santa with a wishlist for everyone in the group, or use our Christmas list maker to share one list with the whole family.

Send one link, get the gifts you want

Save gifts from any store in one free wishlist. Friends reserve in secret, so nobody doubles up.

Make my wishlist

4.9(1,000+ reviews worldwide)