"Three kids means three birthday lists plus Christmas. Before this, my family would text each other asking 'did you already get the LEGO set?' Now they just check the list. Problem solved."
Jenny M.
Mother of 3
WishApp
Elfster vs WishApp
Elfster has been running since 2004 and owns the Secret Santa category with 40 million users across 50+ countries. WishApp is newer, has zero ads, and lets your friends see your wishlist without an account. Here's the honest comparison.
We built WishApp, so we're biased. But we'll be honest.
Last updated: February 2026
The quick version
Elfster
The go-to Secret Santa platform with 40 million users
- 40 million registered users across 50+ countries
- 22+ years running, founded 2004 and fully bootstrapped with no outside investors
- Smart exclusion rules for group gift exchanges
- Anonymous Q&A so gift-givers can ask questions without revealing identity
WishApp
Privacy-first wishlist that works with every store
- Works with any online store, not just affiliate partners
- Zero ads, zero trackers, zero data selling
- Hidden reservations keep gifts a surprise
- Free forever with no premium tier
Feature-by-feature comparison
How Elfster and WishApp stack up on the things that actually matter.
| Feature | Elfster | WishApp |
|---|---|---|
| Ease of use | ||
| Mobile app | ||
| Browser extension | ||
| Works with any store | ||
| Secret Santa | ||
| Hidden reservations | ||
| Anonymous Q&A | ||
| Direct gift shipping | ||
| Group gifting | ||
| No account to view lists | ||
| No ads or trackers | ||
| Collaborative wishlists | ||
| Free (no premium tier) |
What actually sets them apart
Elfster is a Secret Santa machine. WishApp is a wishlist with Secret Santa built in.
Elfster built its entire identity around group gift exchanges. Secret Santa, White Elephant, Yankee Swap, custom exchanges for 3 to 300+ people. Smart exclusion rules to prevent couples from drawing each other. Anonymous Q&A so you can ask your giftee questions without blowing your cover. That depth is genuinely impressive. WishApp has Secret Santa too. But the core product is the wishlist: hidden reservations, group gifting, collaborative lists. If organizing elaborate group exchanges is your main need, Elfster has been doing it for 22 years. WishApp is the better fit if you want a full wishlist experience with Secret Santa as one feature among several.
Affiliate links are everywhere
Elfster earns revenue from affiliate links to hundreds of retailers. That means the gift ideas you browse, the products they surface, the curated gift guides inside the app: all of it runs on commission. Elfster is free, but the experience is built around steering you toward purchases through their partners. WishApp has zero affiliate relationships. No curated gift guides, no sponsored suggestions. You paste a URL from any store, and the item lands in your list. That's it.
Technical problems that have been there a while
Elfster has 40 million users and substantial revenue. But look at the reviews and you'll find a consistent thread: login issues, users unable to join groups after accepting invitations, loading screens that don't clear, purchased item tracking that broke after iOS updates. Multiple users report getting no response from support at all. For an app with 22 years of history, that's a real red flag. WishApp is newer and smaller, but actively maintained. When something breaks, it gets fixed.
No account required to see your lists
Elfster requires your friends to sign up before they can view your wishlist or participate in a gift exchange. That friction adds up, especially when you're sending a list to relatives who aren't tech-savvy. WishApp lets anyone see your wishlist with just a link. No account, no app download, no email address required. Your uncle who only checks email twice a week? He can still see what you want for the holidays.
When to pick each one
Pick Elfster if you...
- Organize group gift exchanges like Secret Santa or White Elephant every year
- Want anonymous Q&A so gift-givers can ask your giftee questions privately
- Need smart exclusion rules to control who can draw whom in large groups
- Want to buy and ship gifts directly through integrated retailers without leaving the app
Pick WishApp if you...
- Want a full wishlist experience with hidden reservations and group gifting
- Care about privacy and don't want your gift browsing monetized through affiliate links
- Need friends to view your list without creating an account
- Want a clean experience with zero ads and zero trackers
52,000+ wishlists and 150,000+ gifts reserved for birthdays, weddings, and every occasion worth celebrating
"My girlfriend and I share lists with each other. I can reserve stuff without her knowing, which makes birthdays way less stressful. The hidden reservation thing is actually clutch."
Theo P.
College Student
"We used this instead of a traditional registry. Added items from 11 different stores. Stuff we actually wanted, not just whatever one store had. Our guests said it was easier too."
Leila R.
Recent Bride
Frequently asked questions
Elfster vs WishApp: the full picture
How Elfster became the Secret Santa default
Elfster launched in 2004, founded by Peter Imburg after his wife and sister-in-law struggled to coordinate a family Secret Santa in December 2000. The platform grew to 40 million registered users across 50+ countries, fully bootstrapped with no venture capital or angel investment. That's a genuinely impressive run. TechRadar called it "the app that took the stress out of my Secret Santa experience." For organizing group gift exchanges at scale, it's been the dominant platform for over two decades.
Where Elfster runs into trouble
The complaints are consistent across review platforms. Login issues. Users told "You are not participating" despite accepting invitations. Loading screens that never clear. Purchased item tracking that broke after iOS updates. Customer service that doesn't respond to emails or voicemails. Elfster has 40 million users and a real revenue stream, so these aren't small-team growing pains. They're long-standing problems that haven't been prioritized. WishApp is a much smaller platform, but it's actively maintained. Bugs get fixed. Support responds.
Which one should you actually pick?
Honestly, if your main use case is organizing a group Secret Santa or White Elephant exchange with smart exclusion rules and anonymous Q&A, Elfster is purpose-built for that and has 22 years of experience doing it. But if you want a wishlist app that also has Secret Santa, works with any store, has zero ads, and lets your friends see your list without signing up, WishApp is built for that. Neither costs a penny. You can try both and have a clear answer in under five minutes.
40,000+ people already making wishlists
Start your free wishlist from any store
Create your first wishlist in under 60 seconds. Free forever, no ads.
Create my wishlist → No duplicate gifts Friends reserve in secret Works with any store