Skip to content

MyRegistry vs. WishApp (2026 Comparison)

MyRegistry and WishApp gift registry apps shown side by side

MyRegistry has run its universal gift registry since 2005, with cash funds, store sync and a large retailer network. Below, we set it against WishApp on price, ads, devices and keeping gifts a surprise.

Last updated: October 2026

MyRegistry is a mature universal registry with cash funds and store sync, but it runs ads and lets the owner see what's been bought. WishApp is free, has no ads, hides reservations from the owner and works in every browser and on macOS. Of the MyRegistry alternatives, it's the one we'd pick.

Feature comparison

MyRegistry is ahead on cash funds, store registry sync and its barcode scanner.

FeatureMyRegistryWishApp
Pricing & value
Free to create and shareFreeFree
Ad-free for youShows adsNo ads
Cash gift fundsYes, fees applyNot offered
No fees on giftingCash fund feesNo fees
Platforms & devices
iPhone and Android appsYesYes
iPad and Android tablet layoutsPhone onlyYes
macOS desktop appBrowser onlyYes
Browser extensionsChrome onlyFive browsers
Raycast quick-addNoYes
Sharing & privacy
Share with one linkYesYes
Friends view without an accountYesYes
Hidden reservations (owner cannot see)Owner can seeHidden
No ads to your guestsGuests see adsNo ads
Gifting features
Sync existing store registriesYesNo sync
Group gifting / pooled contributionsYesYes
Secret Santa / gift exchangeYesYes
Reserved and received trackingMarked boughtYes
Collaborative listsNoYes
Ease of use
Add from any store by pasting a linkHit and missAuto-fills
Barcode scanner for in-store itemsYesNo
Save a product in one click while browsingChrome, desktopYes

A closer look

Pricing and value

Both apps are free to create and share. The difference is ads and fees. MyRegistry is paid for by advertising, so you and your guests see display ads and sponsored product suggestions throughout. Its cash gift funds cost money too: PayPal takes 2.5%, and each gift carries a handling charge of $3.95 to $6.95 depending on the amount. WishApp has no ads, no cash fund and no fees on anything.

Platforms and devices

MyRegistry has a web app, an iPhone app and an Android app, and that's it. There's no macOS app, no Firefox or Safari extension and no Raycast, only a Chrome extension that works on desktop. The iOS app is built for iPhone with no iPad version, and the Android app has no tablet layout. WishApp runs on iPhone, iPad, Android phones and tablets and macOS, with extensions for Chrome, Edge, Firefox, Opera and Safari and a Raycast add-on.

Sharing, privacy and reservations

Both share with one link and let friends view without an account. But on MyRegistry, guests mark gifts as bought and the registrant can often see what's been claimed, so less stays a secret. WishApp hides reservations completely: the owner never sees who claimed what. MyRegistry also shows ads to your guests inside the registry. WishApp doesn't.

Gifting and group features

Both apps let several people chip in on an expensive item. Beyond that, MyRegistry does more. It can sync an existing Amazon or Target registry into one list and keep the retailer perks, host a full Secret Santa exchange, and take cash gifts or nonprofit donations. WishApp doesn't sync registries or take cash gifts. It does run Secret Santa, supports collaborative lists and tracks what you've reserved and received, noting who each gift came from.

Ease of use and adding items

MyRegistry works well once it's set up, but adding items is hit and miss. The reliable way in is the Chrome extension, which is desktop only. On mobile, several reviews say a pasted link often doesn't pull in the product, so you type the price yourself, and the listed price doesn't change when a sale ends. WishApp takes any product link and fills in the title, image and price, or saves the product in one click from the browser extension.

Which one is right for you?

Choose MyRegistry if…

  • You already have registries at Amazon, Target or Macy's and want them in one link without losing the retailer perks.
  • You're planning a wedding or baby shower in the US or Canada and want cash funds or charity donations built in.
  • You want to scan barcodes to add items while you're in a shop.
  • You want friends' lists and birthday reminders in the same app, and you're fine with ads in return for a free service.

Choose WishApp if…

  • You want a list with no ads, where friends see your wishes and no sponsored suggestions.
  • You want reservations hidden from you so gifts stay a real surprise.
  • You add items from Safari, Firefox, a Mac or your phone, not only from Chrome on a desktop.
  • You shop at small or indie stores, where MyRegistry often fails to pick up the product.

MyRegistry FAQ

Yes. Creating, sharing and syncing a registry costs nothing. MyRegistry makes its money from ads and affiliate commissions, so you and your guests see ads. Cash gifts cost extra: PayPal takes 2.5%, plus a handling charge of $3.95 to $6.95 per gift. WishApp is free, with no ads and no fees on any feature.

Yes, there's an iPhone app and an Android app. Both were redesigned in October 2025 and updated again in 2026. There's no iPad version, no Android tablet layout and no macOS app, so on a computer you use the website. The Android listing on Google Play says it contains ads. WishApp has native apps for iPhone, iPad, Android phones and tablets, and macOS.

WishApp, if you don't need a wedding or baby registry. It's free, has no ads, hides reservations so gifts stay a surprise, and works in every major browser, on macOS and in Raycast. MyRegistry is stronger on registry sync and cash funds, so if you need those for a wedding or baby shower, look at it first.

Yes, but only for Chrome and other Chromium browsers, and only on desktop. There's no Firefox or Safari extension, and it isn't listed in Edge's own add-on store. On the Chrome Web Store it has 200,000+ users and a high rating. WishApp's extension works in Chrome, Edge, Firefox, Opera and Safari and saves any product in one click.

Yes, and it's MyRegistry's best feature. You can pull registries from Amazon, Target, Macy's and other stores into one list and keep retailer perks like completion discounts. The catch is on the guest side: after buying a synced item on the retailer's site, a guest has to go back to MyRegistry and mark it bought, which is easy to forget. WishApp has no sync.

Not fully. Guests mark what they've bought so nobody doubles up, but the registrant can often see what's been claimed, which spoils some of the surprise. WishApp hides reservations from the list owner completely, so you don't know who reserved a gift until you open it.

Yes. Paste your MyRegistry list's link into WishApp's import and the items come over in one go. It's a one-time copy, so it won't keep syncing with retailer registries the way MyRegistry does. New items are quick to add: paste a product link and WishApp fills in the title, image and price.

Compare other wishlist apps

Choosing between more than two apps? Our ranking of the best wishlist apps compares them side by side.

Getting ready for the holidays? Draw names for Secret Santa with a wishlist for everyone in the group, or use our Christmas list maker to share one list with the whole family.

Send one link, get the gifts you want

Save gifts from any store in one free wishlist. Friends reserve in secret, so nobody doubles up.

Make my wishlist

4.9(1,000+ reviews worldwide)