Skip to content

GimmeThat vs. WishApp (2026 Comparison)

GimmeThat compared with WishApp, two wishlist tools side by side

GimmeThat is a tidy Chrome extension for saving products you want to buy later. We compared its single private list with WishApp on devices, sharing and the gifting features that turn a save-for-later button into a wishlist other people can use.

Last updated: October 2026

GimmeThat is a private Chrome extension for desktop that saves products to one flat list. There's no mobile app, it doesn't run in Firefox or Safari, and you can't share a list or let anyone reserve a gift. WishApp is free, works on phones, desktops and every major browser, and adds sharing, hidden reservations and Secret Santa. If you're looking for a GimmeThat alternative, WishApp is the one we'd pick.

Feature comparison

GimmeThat's terms describe price and availability alerts, the only row where it leads.

FeatureGimmeThatWishApp
Pricing & value
Free to use todayFree for nowFree forever
No subscription plannedPaid tier reservedAffiliate-only
No adsNo adsNo ads
Platforms & devices
Chrome and Chromium browsersChrome, Edge, Brave, OperaAll four, and more
Firefox and Safari extensionsNeither supportedBoth
iPhone, iPad and Android appsDesktop onlyiOS and Android
macOS appNoYes
Raycast quick-addNoYes
Sharing & privacy
Share a list with one linkPrivate list onlyYes
Friends view without an accountNoYes
Multiple wishlistsOne flat listUnlimited
Price and availability alertsIn its termsNot offered
Gifting features
Hidden reservations (owner cannot see)NoYes
Secret Santa / gift exchangeNoYes
Reserved and received trackingNoYes
Collaborative listsNoYes
Ease of use
One-click save while browsingToolbar buttonToolbar button
Add items without installing anythingExtension requiredWeb, apps or paste a link
Use your list on a phoneNo mobile accessNative apps

A closer look

Pricing and value

Both are free right now, but the small print differs. WishApp is free forever and funded by affiliate links, with no paid tier anywhere in the product. GimmeThat is also free and affiliate-funded today. Its Terms, though, describe the current plan as a 'Free Trial for an unlimited period' and already include subscription billing that can be switched on with notice. So GimmeThat stays free only as long as it chooses to. WishApp has no clause like that.

Platforms and devices

Devices are the biggest gap. GimmeThat is a desktop browser extension and nothing else. It runs in Chrome, Edge, Brave and Opera, not in Firefox or Safari, and there's no mobile app. Its own site says it only works in desktop and laptop browsers. WishApp runs on iPhone, iPad, Android and macOS, in all five browsers including Firefox and Safari, and in Raycast. Save a gift on your phone and it's on your laptop when you sit down.

Sharing, privacy and reservations

GimmeThat keeps your list to yourself. That's deliberate, since it's built as a private 'save for later' tool, but it means there's no link to share, no way for friends to open your list and no reservations. WishApp works the other way. You share a list with one link, people open it without an account, and they reserve gifts in secret so nobody buys the same thing twice. If you want to actually receive the things on your list, that decides it.

Gifting and group features

GimmeThat has nothing for gift-giving: no hidden reservations, no Secret Santa, no shared editing and no tracking of what's been reserved or received. It works more like a smarter bookmark folder than a gift registry. WishApp is built around the people buying for you. You can run a Secret Santa draw, manage a family list together, and keep an archive of received gifts with notes on who gave what.

Ease of use and adding items

Saving items is where GimmeThat shines. One click on its toolbar button grabs the product name, image, price and link, and you can correct the details if it guesses wrong. Its terms also say it may watch saved items and email you when the price or stock changes, which WishApp doesn't do. WishApp matches the one-click save and also fills in the details from any link you paste. If all you want is a quiet save-for-later button on your desktop, GimmeThat does that job well.

Which one is right for you?

Choose GimmeThat if…

  • You stay in a Chromium browser on a desktop and just want a fast, private button for saving products to buy later.
  • You want price and availability alerts. GimmeThat's terms say it can email you when a saved item changes.
  • You never need to share your list, open it on a phone, or let anyone reserve a gift from it.

Choose WishApp if…

  • You want to share a wishlist with family or friends and let them reserve gifts in secret.
  • You add gifts from your phone, or browse in Firefox or Safari, neither of which GimmeThat supports.
  • You want multiple lists for birthdays, weddings and Christmas instead of one flat list.
  • You run a Secret Santa, share lists with family, or want it all free with no subscription clause in the Terms.

GimmeThat FAQ

Yes, for now. GimmeThat is free today and funded by affiliate links, not ads. The catch is in its Terms, which call the current plan a 'Free Trial for an unlimited period' and include subscription billing that can be switched on with notice. WishApp is free forever, with no paid tier and no clause like that.

No. GimmeThat is a desktop browser extension only, with no iPhone, iPad or Android app. Its own site says it only works in desktop and laptop browsers, so you can't check your saved list on a phone. WishApp has native apps for iOS, iPadOS and Android as well as its browser extensions.

No. GimmeThat runs in Chrome, Edge, Brave and Opera, and its site says it doesn't work in Firefox or Safari. That rules out a large share of desktop users. WishApp has its own Firefox and Safari extensions alongside the Chromium ones.

No. GimmeThat is built as a private 'save for later' list, with no share link and no gift reservations, so friends can't view your list or claim items. WishApp works the other way round. You share a list with one link, friends reserve gifts in secret, and you never see who claimed what.

WishApp, as soon as you want to share a list. It's free forever, works on phones, desktops and five browsers including Firefox and Safari, and adds sharing, hidden reservations, multiple lists and Secret Santa. GimmeThat's one advantage is the price and availability alerts its terms describe, so if a private price tracker on your desktop is all you need, start there.

No. Going by its site and extension description, GimmeThat keeps everything in one private list, with no separate lists or folders. WishApp gives you unlimited wishlists, each with its own title, description and cover image, so birthdays, weddings and Christmas stay apart.

GimmeThat doesn't document an export feature, so plan on re-adding your items by hand rather than importing them. WishApp makes that quick: give it a product link and the title, image and price come in on their own, or save items in one click with the browser extension.

Compare other wishlist apps

Choosing between more than two apps? Our ranking of the best wishlist apps compares them side by side.

Getting ready for the holidays? Draw names for Secret Santa with a wishlist for everyone in the group, or use our Christmas list maker to share one list with the whole family.

Send one link, get the gifts you want

Save gifts from any store in one free wishlist. Friends reserve in secret, so nobody doubles up.

Make my wishlist

4.9(1,000+ reviews worldwide)