GimmeThat is a tidy little Chrome extension for saving products you want to buy later. Here is how its single private list stacks up against WishApp on devices, sharing, and the gifting features that separate a save-for-later tool from a real wishlist.
Last updated: June 2026
Looking for a GimmeThat alternative? GimmeThat is a private, desktop-only Chrome extension for saving products to one flat list. It has no mobile app, no Firefox or Safari, and no way to share lists or reserve gifts. WishApp is free, runs everywhere, and adds sharing, hidden reservations and Secret Santa. Among GimmeThat alternatives, WishApp is the one we'd pick.
Every row reflects what each tool actually does today. GimmeThat genuinely wins a couple, so we marked those too.
| Feature | GimmeThat | WishApp |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing & value | ||
| Free to use today | Free for now | Free forever |
| No subscription planned | Paid tier reserved | Affiliate-only |
| No ads | No ads | No ads |
| Platforms & devices | ||
| Chrome and Chromium browsers | Chrome, Edge, Brave, Opera | All five plus more |
| Firefox and Safari extensions | Neither supported | Both |
| iPhone, iPad and Android apps | Desktop only | iOS + Android |
| macOS app | No | Yes |
| Raycast quick-add | No | Yes |
| Sharing & privacy | ||
| Share a list with one link | Private only | Yes |
| Friends view without an account | No | Yes |
| Multiple wishlists | One flat list | Unlimited |
| Price and availability alerts | Yes, by email | Not offered |
| Gifting features | ||
| Hidden reservations (owner cannot see) | No | Yes |
| Secret Santa / gift exchange | No | Yes |
| Reserved and received tracking | No | Yes |
| Collaborative lists | No | Yes |
| Ease of use | ||
| One-click save while browsing | Toolbar button | Toolbar button |
| Add items without installing anything | Extension required | Web, apps or paste a link |
| Use your list on a phone | No mobile access | Native apps |
Both are free right now, but the small print differs. WishApp is free forever, funded by affiliate links, with no paid tier anywhere in the product. GimmeThat is also free and affiliate-funded today, except its Terms describe the current plan as an 'unlimited free trial' and ship with full subscription billing ready to switch on. So GimmeThat is free until it decides not to be. WishApp has no such clause.
This is the biggest gap. GimmeThat is a desktop browser extension and nothing else. It runs in Chrome, Edge, Brave and Opera, but not Firefox or Safari, and there is no mobile app at all. The site spells it out: it only works on desktop and laptop browsers. WishApp runs on iPhone, iPad, Android, macOS, all five browsers including Firefox and Safari, plus Raycast. Save a gift on your phone, see it on your laptop.
GimmeThat keeps your list to yourself. That is by design, since it is built as a private 'save for later' tool, but it means there is no shareable link, no way for friends to open your list, and no reservations. WishApp is the opposite: share a list with one link, let people view it without an account, and let them secretly reserve gifts so nobody buys the same thing twice. If you want to actually receive gifts, that distinction is the whole game.
GimmeThat has no gifting layer. No hidden reservations, no Secret Santa, no shared editing, no reserved or received tracking. It is closer to a smarter bookmark folder than a gift registry. WishApp is built for the social side: run a Secret Santa draw, co-manage a family list, and keep a 'received' archive with notes like 'from Sarah' so you remember who gave what. Different jobs entirely.
Here GimmeThat is genuinely good. One click on its toolbar button grabs the product name, image, price and link, and you can fix the details if it guesses wrong. It even watches some items and emails you when a price or stock level changes, which WishApp does not do. WishApp matches the one-click save and adds auto-fill from any pasted link, but if a quiet desktop save-for-later button is all you need, GimmeThat nails that one thing.
Create your first wishlist in under 60 seconds. Free forever, no ads.
Create my wishlist →