Skip to content

Amazon Wishlist vs. WishApp (2026 Comparison)

Amazon Wishlist and WishApp side by side

Amazon Wishlist is the one almost everyone already has. This comparison looks at which stores you can add from, who can open your list, how reservations work, and what Amazon's 2026 address change means for you.

Last updated: October 2026

Looking for an Amazon Wishlist alternative? Amazon Wishlist is free and hard to beat for one-click adds while you shop on Amazon. But it only takes Amazon products, the share link often sends people to a login page, and since March 2026 a gift bought from a third-party seller gives that seller your address. WishApp adds from any store and opens for anyone, so it's our pick among Amazon Wishlist alternatives.

Feature comparison

Amazon wins on price-drop alerts for its own items and adding by Alexa.

FeatureAmazon WishlistWishApp
Pricing & value
Free to useFreeFree forever
No ads or data targetingUsed for adsNo ads
Price drop alertsAmazon itemsNot offered
Adding items
Add from any storeAmazon onlyAny website
One-click add inside AmazonBest in classAuto-fills details
Browser extensionNone since 2023Five browsers
Voice / Alexa addAlexaNo
Platforms & devices
iPhone, iPad and Android appsInside Amazon appDedicated apps
macOS desktop appWeb onlyYes
Raycast quick-addNoYes
Sharing & privacy
Friends view without an accountOften a login wallYes, reliably
Address kept private from sellersShared since March 2026Never shared
Multiple currencies on one listOne per regional storeAll currencies
QR code for any listNoYes
Gifting features
Hidden reservations (owner cannot see)Spoiler toggle, often buggyHidden from owner
Reserve without buyingMust purchaseYes
Group gifting / cash poolRegistries onlyYes
Reserved and received trackingNoYes

What sets them apart

Pricing and value

Both are free, but they make money in different ways. WishApp earns only from affiliate links: no ads, no tracking, and your data is never sold. Amazon Wishlist costs nothing either, but as one reviewer put it, you are the product. Amazon uses your list for ad targeting and product recommendations. You get a huge catalog, and Amazon learns what you want to buy.

Adding items and the Amazon catalog

Inside Amazon, nothing beats it. One tap on Add to List saves a product with the right title, image and price, you can add by voice with Alexa, and you get an alert when an item drops in price. Outside Amazon, you're stuck. Amazon shut down its Amazon Assistant extension in March 2023, and since then the list only takes Amazon products, so a gift from Etsy, IKEA or a local shop can't go on it. WishApp takes a link from any store and fills in the details, or saves the product in one click with its extension for Chrome, Edge, Firefox, Opera or Safari.

Sharing, privacy and the 2026 address change

This is where Amazon falls down. More and more often, people without an Amazon account who open a shared list get sent to a login page, even when the list is set to Shared. One user said it still failed half the time across different browsers. Then on March 25 2026, Amazon removed the option to block third-party sellers on list items. When someone buys you a gift from one of those sellers, the seller now gets your delivery address. Amazon's advice was to get a P.O. Box. WishApp links open for anyone without an account, and WishApp never shares your address.

Reservations and surprise protection

Amazon's Don't Spoil My Surprises setting is on by default, but people report it as buggy. One user's sister saw her whole list marked as bought after the setting failed on her phone. Friends also can't claim an item without buying it on Amazon. On WishApp, reservations are hidden from the owner by design: friends claim gifts in secret, the owner never sees who reserved what, and nobody has to buy anything to reserve it. Both offer group gifting, where several people pool money toward a big item, but on Amazon it only comes with wedding and baby registries.

Ease of use and getting started

If you already shop on Amazon, the easiest list is the one you already have. There's no new app and no sign-up, and adding takes one tap. That reach is Amazon's biggest strength. The rough edges show up later. People call moving items between lists a nightmare, copying the link from the address bar instead of using the Invite button gives friends a link that breaks, and there's no export if you ever want to leave. WishApp was built as a gift app first, not a store with a list bolted on, so it's designed around sharing and reserving, not selling.

Amazon's list or WishApp?

Choose Amazon Wishlist if…

  • You buy almost everything on Amazon and want the list you already have, with one-tap adds and a huge catalog.
  • Everyone in your family has an Amazon account, so login walls on shared links won't stop them.
  • You want built-in price-drop alerts on Amazon items, or you like adding things by voice with Alexa.
  • You're setting up a wedding or baby registry and want it on Amazon, with group gifting for big items.

Choose WishApp if…

  • You shop at more than one store and want to add gifts from Etsy, IKEA, a local boutique or anywhere else.
  • You want friends to open your list without an Amazon account or a login wall.
  • You care about privacy and don't want sellers getting your address or your list used for ad targeting.
  • You want reservations the owner truly can't see, plus apps for iPhone, iPad, Android, macOS and five browsers.

Amazon Wishlist FAQ

Yes. It comes with any Amazon account, and there's no paid tier or premium upgrade. The catch is that Amazon uses your list for ad targeting and product recommendations, so you pay with data about what you want to buy instead of cash. WishApp is free too. It earns from affiliate links, shows no ads and never sells your data.

No, not since March 2023. That's when Amazon shut down its Amazon Assistant browser extension, and it never released a replacement, so you can only add products from Amazon's own catalog. Items from Target, Etsy, IKEA or any other store can't go on the list. WishApp works the other way around: paste a link from any website and it fills in the title, image and price.

No. Amazon Assistant, the extension that used to save products from any site, was shut down on Chrome, Firefox, Edge and Opera in March 2023, and there's no official replacement. WishApp has extensions for Chrome, Edge, Firefox, Opera and Safari that save any product in one click while you browse.

In theory, yes. In practice it often fails. Since 2025, people who share lists set to Shared report that friends without an Amazon account get sent to a login page, and one said it still failed half the time. WishApp links open for anyone without an account, which is the whole point of sending someone your list.

Less than it used to be. On March 25 2026, Amazon removed the option to restrict list purchases to items sold by Amazon. Now, when someone buys you a gift from a third-party seller, that seller gets your delivery address. Amazon's suggested workaround was a P.O. Box. WishApp never shares your address with anyone and uses no tracking.

WishApp, if you buy from more than one store. It adds gifts from any store, not just Amazon, opens for anyone without an account, keeps your address private, and hides reservations from the owner. Amazon's real strengths are its catalog and price-drop alerts, so if you do all your shopping on Amazon, the built-in list still works well.

Yes. Paste the link to a shared Amazon wishlist into WishApp's import and the items come over in one go. After that, paste any product link, Amazon links included, and the title, image and price fill in automatically.

Compare other wishlist apps

Choosing between more than two apps? Our ranking of the best wishlist apps compares them side by side.

Getting ready for the holidays? Draw names for Secret Santa with a wishlist for everyone in the group, or use our Christmas list maker to share one list with the whole family.

Send one link, get the gifts you want

Save gifts from any store in one free wishlist. Friends reserve in secret, so nobody doubles up.

Make my wishlist

4.9(1,000+ reviews worldwide)