Skip to content

Giftster vs. WishApp (2026 Comparison)

Giftster compared with WishApp, two family wishlist apps side by side

Giftster has run family gift exchanges since 2008 and says it has over 3 million members. We compared its family groups, Secret Santa and child accounts with WishApp on price, devices and ads, and on the sign-up step, where less tech-savvy relatives tend to get stuck.

Last updated: October 2026

Looking for a Giftster alternative? Giftster is a mature, free app for family groups, with Secret Santa, child accounts and a birthday calendar. But it reportedly shows Google ads, and every relative needs an account to see a group list. WishApp is free and has no ads. Friends open your list from one link without downloading anything, and reserve gifts in secret. Among Giftster alternatives, WishApp is our pick.

Feature comparison

Giftster has two things WishApp lacks: a birthday calendar and accounts for children and pets.

FeatureGiftsterWishApp
Pricing & value
Free, no paid tierFreeFree forever
No adsGoogle adsNo ads
Unlimited lists and itemsUnlimitedUnlimited
Platforms & devices
iPhone, iPad and Android appsiOS + AndroidiOS + Android
macOS desktop appiOS app on MacYes
Browser extensionsFour browsersSix browsers
Raycast quick-addNoYes
Sharing & privacy
View a shared list without an accountPublic lists onlyYes
QR code for a listNoYes
Multiple currenciesUSD-centricAll currencies
More than one languageEnglish only26 languages
Gifting & group features
Hidden reservations (owner cannot see)YesYes
Secret Santa name drawBuilt inYes
Birthday calendarYesNot offered
Child and pet accountsYesNot offered
Collaborative adult listsChild lists onlyYes
Ease of use
Add from any store by pasting a linkFetch is flakyAuto-fills
Save a product in one click while browsingYesYes
Received tracking with personal notesBasic archiveWith notes

Point by point

Pricing and value

Both apps are free, with no paid tier and unlimited lists. The difference is ads. WishApp earns money only from affiliate links and never shows ads. Giftster earns affiliate commissions too, but WRDW and ABC 6 News reported Google display ads inside the app over the 2024 holidays. Neither app costs you money. On Giftster you pay with some of your attention instead.

Platforms and devices

Close call. Giftster has solid iPhone, iPad and Android apps, and in November 2024 it added extensions for Chrome, Firefox, Safari and Edge. WishApp has the same apps, extensions for two more browsers (Brave and Opera), a real macOS app and a Raycast add-on. Giftster's iOS app does run on Apple Silicon Macs, but there's no purpose-built desktop version and no Raycast.

Sharing, privacy and the sign-up wall

This is Giftster's biggest drawback. Everything happens inside a closed family group, and you need a Giftster account to see a list shared there. Reviews describe less tech-savvy relatives getting stuck at sign-up. With WishApp, someone opens a link, sees the whole list and reserves a gift in seconds. WishApp also has QR codes, every currency and 26 languages. Giftster is English-only and built around the US, and its App Store privacy labels say data may be collected.

Gifting and group features

Giftster earns its keep here. Everyone in the family keeps a list in one shared group, and the group comes with a birthday calendar, child and pet accounts and a Secret Santa draw that even the organizer can't see. Members can also secretly suggest items for each other's lists. WishApp has Secret Santa and hidden reservations too, plus collaborative adult lists, which Giftster lacks. But it has no birthday calendar or child accounts. For a big family spanning several generations, Giftster does more.

Ease of use and adding items

Giftster feels familiar and works well once the group is set up, and its iOS app holds 4.8 stars from 18,000 ratings. Reliability is the weak spot. Reviewers keep complaining about Fetch auto-fill and photo upload ('I can't even get it to pull up the upload photo option', one wrote in December 2024), and some get logged out at random. WishApp pulls the title, image and price from any link with a dedicated server-side scraper, and the extension saves a product in one click.

Giftster or WishApp?

Choose Giftster if…

  • Your large family spans several generations, gives gifts year-round and wants everyone's lists in one shared group.
  • You rely on the birthday calendar and child or pet accounts to manage gifts for kids and relatives.
  • You want a built-in Secret Santa draw and don't mind that every member needs an account.
  • You're already set up on Giftster and switching the whole family feels like more hassle than it's worth.

Choose WishApp if…

  • You want friends to open a link and reserve a gift in seconds, with no ads.
  • You shop outside the US, or need more than one currency or language.
  • You want a real macOS app, Raycast, and extensions across six browsers including Brave and Opera.
  • You want auto-fill that works and a shared list two adults can run together, not only child lists.

Giftster FAQ

Yes. Giftster has no paid tier, subscription or per-feature charge. It earns affiliate commissions when people buy through its links, and press reports describe Google display ads inside the app. WishApp is free too, with no ads.

Yes. Giftster has apps for iPhone, iPad and Android, and the iOS app is rated 4.8 stars from about 18,000 ratings. There's no purpose-built macOS app, though the iOS app runs on Apple Silicon Macs. WishApp covers the same phones and tablets and adds a real macOS app and a Raycast add-on.

For most people, WishApp. It's free with no ads, friends see your list and reserve gifts from one link without downloading anything, and it runs on phones, desktop and six browsers in 26 languages. Giftster's strength is the family group with its birthday calendar and child accounts, so a big family already settled there may prefer to stay.

Reportedly, yes. Giftster's own pricing page doesn't mention ads, but WRDW and ABC 6 News reported Google display ads inside the app during the 2024 holiday season. WishApp shows no ads anywhere and earns only from affiliate links, with no sponsored feed.

For almost everything, yes. Creating lists, joining a group and reserving gifts all need a free Giftster account, and so does viewing a list shared within a group. Only public lists open without an account. On WishApp, anyone with the link sees the whole list and can reserve a gift in seconds.

Yes. In November 2024 Giftster launched extensions for Chrome, Firefox, Safari and Edge, so you can save a product in one click while browsing. Brave and Opera aren't officially supported. WishApp's extension works in all four plus Brave and Opera, and there's a Raycast add-on too.

Yes. Paste a Giftster list's share link into WishApp's import and the wishes come over in one go, though the whole family would still need to switch together. New items are quick to add: paste a product link and WishApp fills in the title, image and price, or save items in one click with the extension.

Compare other wishlist apps

Choosing between more than two apps? Our ranking of the best wishlist apps compares them side by side.

Getting ready for the holidays? Draw names for Secret Santa with a wishlist for everyone in the group, or use our Christmas list maker to share one list with the whole family.

Send one link, get the gifts you want

Save gifts from any store in one free wishlist. Friends reserve in secret, so nobody doubles up.

Make my wishlist

4.9(1,000+ reviews worldwide)